Arcade game machines themselves are inanimate objects; they do not inherently handle community guidelines. The creation, enforcement, and management of player-created rules are entirely community-driven and supported by arcade operators. These informal guidelines emerge organically from dedicated player bases for competitive or popular games.

The primary method of handling these guidelines is through social consensus and peer pressure. In a physical arcade, experienced players often mentor newcomers on unwritten rules, such as waiting your turn (often symbolized by placing a token on the machine's bezel), character selection etiquette in fighting games, and acknowledging skilled play. For high-score chasers, guidelines might include not resetting a machine without permission or properly recording initials.

Arcade operators play a crucial role by providing a conducive environment. They may formalize these player-created rules by posting printed guidelines on the wall or directly on the machine. Operators act as arbiters, stepping in to resolve disputes about conduct or alleged cheating, thus upholding the community's standards. In extreme cases, they can ban players who consistently violate the established etiquette.

In the modern era, online forums and Discord servers have become the central hubs for these communities. Here, guidelines are explicitly documented, discussed, and updated. Players collectively decide on rules for tournaments, share techniques, and call out unsportsmanlike behavior, creating a system of accountability that extends beyond the physical arcade. Therefore, the "handling" of community guidelines is a collaborative effort between passionate players and supportive arcade owners to ensure a fair and enjoyable experience for everyone.